Newton North Students Protest Hypocrisy

 

This past May, Newton North High School (NNHS) held a new event, Middle East History Day, during which invited speakers gave presentations throughout the day. We, the NNHS Peace Action Club, were thrilled that faculty and students began open conversations about the Middle East. However, we noticed some hypocrisy in the criteria that the NNHS set for the speakers.

In October of last year, NNHS Peace Action planned to invite Phyllis Bennis, an analyst and writer on the Middle East, to give a presentation about Syria. This proposal was denied because of concerns that Ms. Bennis would spark controversy because she has been critical of Israel’s actions and policies — although the event was to focus entirely on Syria — and the administration did not feel that there was sufficient time to prepare for the expected backlash.

Interested starting a student chapter? Read how here

Then, only a week before Middle East History Day, we learned that the members of the Jewish Student Union had invited Arielle Schwartz, the New England Progressive Outreach Director from AIPAC (American Israel Public Affairs Committee), the powerful, explicitly pro-Israel political lobbying group without previous notifications to the main organizers of the event. If controversy and time constraints made NNHS draw the line at hosting Phyllis Bennis, so should have AIPAC caused discomfort for the administration. But the AIPAC speaker was confirmed.

The NNHS Peace Action responded accordingly: during the AIPAC presentation, two Jewish students held a banner that read “AIPAC does not represent us / Not in our name! #JewishResistance,” and as the audience left the presentation, three other students distributed flyers that gave context on what AIPAC really stands for. The entire protest was civil and nondisruptive, and we hope the administration takes a lesson from our response.

Sure, the Middle East History Day did offer a range of speakers with differing perspectives, including MAPA’s Jeff Klein who discussed Syria; and sure, clubs and students of whatever political stripe may invite whomever they choose. But since that privilege was not extended to my club with Phyllis Bennis, the school should at least have been consistent with the precedent it had set. This incident also prompts these questions: what narratives are schools willing to sanction? When a pro-peace speaker is considered too controversial but rabidly pro-Israel AIPAC is accepted, whose free speech seems to matter more?

Advertisements

From Local Student to Global Citizen: Matthew Hahm

Matthew Hahm, president of Boston College’s student chapter, was accustomed to hearing about war and its inevitableness, but it wasn’t until he took a certain course during his junior year as an undergraduate at Boston College that he was offered an alternative. Through his learning, peace became a possibility to him.

“That course really helped me see that one of the biggest things that we need to do is just try to imagine peace,” said Hahm. “If you believe that it’s not possible, then it will never be possible.”

The following summer, Hahm – originally from Washington state – interned with Massachusetts Peace Action, hoping to help turn around the foreign policy he realized was “wicked” and “corrupt.” The internship gave him the opportunity to attend the Democratic National Convention in Philadelphia with MAPA executive director Cole Harrison. He also went to Washington, D.C. for the Climate March and sat on a student panel at a peace convention.

“MAPA has a lot of cool opportunities for students and interns,” said Hahm. “I think what I gained the most from MAPA was knowledge. The people that work for Peace Action are extremely knowledgeable and very aware of what is going on… they dig beneath the headlines.”

Interested in becoming a Student Organizer? Read more here

During his senior year at Boston College, Hahm started a MAPA student chapter. The club hosted a nuclear weapons educational event, which gathered a sizable crowd for a new organization. After graduating this spring, Hahm left the club to grow in the hands of two co-leaders while he pursues work with the Jesuit Volunteer Corps in Belize. For the next two years, Hahm will help with pastoral ministry work in the parish of a Belize community.

“The idea of being a global citizen is connected to my faith,” said Hahm, a student of sociology and theology. “We shouldn’t see ourselves separate from another, and we need to see how one policy here can affect other people across the world. It’s not right if we infringe on somebody else’s rights so that we can gain more as a nation.”